Former Dons defender Alex McLeish believes the club must look beyond the dugout if they want to solve their persistent problems.
McLeish has identified recruitment as the real issue facing the Scottish Premiership side. He insists that appointing another manager will achieve little unless Aberdeen improve the quality of players brought into the squad.
Stuart Duff has been placed in interim charge following Stephen Robinson’s dismissal on Monday. The club must now begin the search for a permanent successor.
However, McLeish believes the managerial change should not distract the hierarchy from a much bigger challenge. For him, the quality of recruitment will determine whether the next appointment succeeds or struggles.
The former Aberdeen defender was disappointed to see Robinson lose his job. He had expected the manager to make a positive impact but believes the circumstances around the squad made the task difficult.
“I like Stevie, I thought he’d do a good job. But the bottom line is you can be a manager, but you need to have the players that are going to be able to do that transition for you.
“Recruitment is massive. I’ve been saying this for years. In my calls and my texts to Willie Miller, he must be fed up, I’m saying, ‘Willie, recruitment is the key’. We say it every single year. How can we identify good young players that come to the club?
“If it’s just about bringing another manager in, then there’s something not quite right.”
McLeish’s comments highlight a familiar concern around Aberdeen’s long-term direction. Managers are often expected to transform struggling teams quickly. Yet even the best tactical ideas can fall flat without players capable of delivering them.
The former defender believes Aberdeen need a more reliable approach to identifying and signing talent. That includes finding young players who can develop, improve the squad and help establish greater consistency.
His reference to repeated conversations with Willie Miller also suggests that recruitment has been a longstanding concern. It is not simply a problem that has emerged with Robinson’s departure.
Aberdeen now face two important decisions. They must identify the right manager while also addressing the structures that support the first team.
The next appointment will inevitably attract attention. Supporters will want someone capable of restoring confidence and improving results. But McLeish’s warning raises a bigger question about the club’s ability to build a squad that can consistently compete.
Changing the manager may offer a fresh start. Changing the recruitment approach could determine whether that fresh start actually lasts.

Toosin is a dedicated sports writer with a strong background in crafting engaging and insightful content. With experience at Goal, he has developed a sharp editorial sense and a refined storytelling approach that brings depth and perspective to sports journalism. His passion for the game goes beyond the headlines, as he captures both the excitement of the sport and the compelling human narratives behind each event. Toosin’s work resonates with a broad and diverse audience, making global sports stories accessible, relatable, and impactful.



