Carragher refuses to feel sorry for Carrick after Manchester United exit

Jamie Carragher has refused to sympathise with Michael Carrick following his dismissal as Manchester United head coach. The former Liverpool defender believes Carrick was never qualified to command the level of respect expected of an elite manager.

Carrick’s departure was confirmed on Thursday after a disastrous start to the 2026-27 season. United are in the Premier League relegation zone, with their campaign falling apart despite the promise he showed during his initial spell in charge.

However, Carragher believes the former United midfielder was handed the opportunity largely because of his connection to the club rather than an outstanding managerial record.

“Michael Carrick got the Manchester United job based on NOTHING! He got the job on basically having PLAYED FOR for Manchester United,” said Carragher.

The pundit made it clear that Carrick’s dismissal had not generated any sympathy from him. He argued that the former midfielder’s coaching experience did not justify his appointment at one of England’s biggest clubs.

“I am NOT SAD or FEELING SORRY for Michael Carrick!

“He had 2 years at Middlesbrough, he then did some punditry and they gave him the Manchester United job!

“He got them in the Champions League, yes, but he was NEVER among the caliber of the best managers.”

Carrick’s managerial journey before returning to Old Trafford included two years at Middlesbrough. He subsequently moved into punditry before United turned to him in January following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal.

His initial impact was impressive. Carrick guided United to 12 victories in the remaining 17 Premier League matches of the 2025-26 season. The run secured a third-place finish and Champions League qualification.

That achievement convinced the club to make his appointment permanent in May. He was rewarded with a two-year contract, but the second chapter of his United career proved dramatically different.

The team struggled for consistency and suffered damaging defeats in the Premier League, Carabao Cup and Champions League. Three victories in 15 matches across all competitions ultimately left the club’s leadership questioning his ability to turn things around.

His final match was a remarkable 4-4 draw against Aston Villa. It was not enough to save his position, with United opting for another managerial change.

The club are now closing in on Mauricio Pochettino as they search for Carrick’s successor. Contact has reportedly been made with the United States Soccer Federation as negotiations progress.

Carrick’s exit has reopened questions about United’s managerial recruitment. His previous success offered a compelling argument for continuity, but the collapse in results exposed the risks of the appointment.

Carragher, however, has focused on a different issue: whether Carrick had the managerial pedigree for the job in the first place. His comments leave little room for sympathy, even after a difficult ending to the former midfielder’s time at Old Trafford.

Share This Post On

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Must Read

Recent Posts